2026 September 29
Kinnarath v. Choiselat, 2026 MBCA 79
The Manitoba Court of Appeal, hearing an appeal by the plaintiff, sustained the trial judge’s modest assessment of $5,000 general and $5,000 aggravated damages for defamation but allowed the plaintiff’s appeal to the extent of holding the co-defendant People’s Party of Canada (the PPC) vicariously liable to the plaintiff. On July 22, 2019, the individual defendant Choiselat, a member of the PPC and the CEO of the PPC’s Winnipeg Centre Electoral District Association (the EDA), “posted several defamatory statements to her personal Facebook account” which included a colour photograph of the plaintiff and listed his name, home address (which was out of date), telephone number and email address. Facebook removed those defamatory statements on July 23, 2019 at the plaintiff’s request. Also on July 23, 2019, the defendant Choiselat published the original defamatory post on EDA’s Twitter account. Twitter removed the post later that day. “Once executives in the national PPC office became aware of Choiselat’s actions, the PPC investigated and by August 21, 2019, it had removed her from the position of CEO of the EDA.”
Discussing the modest award of damages by the trial judge, the Manitoba Court of Appeal noted, inter alia: “For his part, the plaintiff took steps that brought attention to the defamatory statements. On July 25, 2019, he posted a screenshot of the Twitter Post to his personal Instagram account with his own commentary. On September 17, 2019, he again republished a screenshot of the Twitter Post to his personal Twitter account, indicating his intention to sue the defendants and others for defamation.” The Appeal Court went on to say that “a significant fact that weighs in favour of a nominal damages award is the plaintiff’s decision to repost the Twitter Post. By doing so, he republished the defamatory material – potentially widening its dissemination.”